Wednesday, February 25, 2009

Do we really want fair?

Last night we began our men's study in the book of Romans. I have been looking forward to this for a while now and the others seem to be excited about the study also. Something came up in our discussion that really impacted me. Someone mentioned how in discussing grace and how it relates with law, works, etc. that some people can't make sense of it because it seems to go against God's "fairness." It hit me because I can remember being one of those who would have said something like this at one time. My rationale would have been something to this effect, "Well 'grace only' salvation doesn't seem to make sense because that means God allows those to be saved who don't deserve it or who have not been righteous followers." Well of course! Isn't that the whole point of grace? I have to admit that I am somewhat embarrassed that I spent a number of years ignoring or shying away from this reality, thinking it was the only way to protect my belief that we must obey God.

Here is a profound thought: Grace is not fair! Grace completely stands against everything that "fairness" is supposed to mean. I think it all makes sense when we understand that Paul's whole point of this law-grace distinction in Romans was to reveal the means or process by which we are saved. His point was not that we don't have to set out to be a holy and righteous people before God who seek to obey Him, but rather it was to inform us that grace sets us free from the necessity of trying to get to Heaven by and through our own means. Our adherence to a law is not the source of our salvation.

Dr. Jack Cottrell, writer of a great book entitled, The Faith Once for All does a superb job in explaining this:

Do I really want God to be fair with me on the day of judgment? Before answering we should remind ourselves that the only fair (just, deserved) treatment for sinners of any kind is hell!

Does this mean that grace is not fair? Of course it does! That is the very point of grace, i.e., that under grace God does not treat us in terms of fairness or justice: he does not pay us the wages our works have earned or deserved. For those who break the commandments, hell is fair. But grace is entirely different; it has nothing to do with fairness.......It is in fact the exact opposite of fairness; it is antifair. It is grace. Such grace is not just "unmerited favor"; it is "favor bestowed when wrath is owed" (pp. 312-313).

The truth of the matter is that if I am saved by law, then that means I must obey all the commandments for my entire life, and I must keep every element of that law perfectly. In other words, I must be totally sinless if it is law that saves me.

For all who rely on works of the law are under a curse; for it is written, Cursed be everyone who does not abide by ALL things written in the Book of the Law, and do them (Galatians 3:10).
For whoever keeps the whole law but fails in one point has become accountable for all of it (James 2:10).

There was only one person who was able to accomplish this. That was Jesus Christ.

For we do not have a high priest who is unable to sympathize with our weaknesses, but one who in every respect has been tempted as we are, yet without sin (Hebrews 4:15).

And so while theoretically, one can be saved by keeping law only in that it was possible for Jesus, the feasibility of us doing it is 0%. We cannot do it.

For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God (Romans 3:23).
But God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us. Since, therefore, we have now been justified by his blood, much more shall we be saved by him from the wrath of God (Romans 5:8-9).

We all sin. Not one of us are perfect. Hence, our need for God's saving grace:

For we maintain that one was justified by faith apart from the works of the law (Romans 3:28).

For sin will have no dominion over you, since you are not under law but under grace (Romans 6:14).

For the wages of sin is death, but the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord (Romans 6:23).

I do not nullify the grace of God, for if righteousness were through the law, then Christ died for no purpose (Galatians 2:21).

For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, not a result of works, so that no one may boast (Ephesians 2:8-9).

Paul also seems to suggest in his letter to Titus that it is God's grace to begin with, that even gives us a means to be righteous servants.

For the grace of God has appeared, bringing salvation for all people, training us to renounce ungodliness and worldly passion, and to live self-controlled, upright, and godly lives in the present age (Titus 2:11-12).

And finally, may we never forget that this saving grace comes to us through none other than the One who was designated from the beginning to be our Savior. Jesus lived a perfect life and set for us the perfect example of how to live in the kingdom. And then He died so that those who belong to Him might have the full benefit of life in the kingdom here on earth and in Heaven. Regardless of how great our citizenship in His kingdom is, it is not because of our doing. We will forever be in debt to God. It is only through Christ and the grace He brought to us, that we even stand a chance, with any hope at all.

Therefore, we are ambassadors for Christ, God making his appeal through us. We implore you on behalf of Christ, be reconciled to God. For our sake, he made him to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God (2 Corinthians 5:20-21).

Thank you Father God for your grace! I know I am undeserving of it. Through your Son Jesus, I bow before your throne recognizing my unworthiness. May I never take advantage of it and make a mockery of your loving grace. But may I never nullify it either. And may my actions toward others continuously reflect your love and grace that you have so extended to the world. Thank you for loving me in spite of my shortcomings. Help me to love others in spite of their shortcomings. Your grace extends to my neighbor as much as it does me. And please, help me to love you, who has no shortcomings, more and more as each day passes. Thank you, Father. Thank you! Amen!

14 comments:

Unknown said...

For the wages of sin is death, but the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord (Romans 6:23)....VERY TRUE, and we get into Christ through obedience to his word...We are baptized into Christ....Galations 3:27...Paul had to arise and be baptized..washing away his sins...Acts22:16...There is no such thing as grace only salvation...Anyone who reads THE WORD OF GOD with an HONEST mind will understand this...There are many more Scriptures supporting grace through OBEDIENCE...

Unknown said...

A comment on my comment...
Salvation is very simple...Jesus and the Apostles have told us...we must obey the plan of salvation...given not because we earned it...but by his Grace...why would one want to argue with The Lord and His Apostles...Hebrews 5:9.

FitandRunning said...

Bill (?),

I am curious as to what part of my post seems to be "arguing with the Lord and His Apostles." I thought I was in complete agreement with them. After all, I quoted quite often from the pen of Paul.

I agree that God wants us to obey Him. I never said anything to the contrary. But is it not still by the grace of God that He has even given us opportunity to obey? Regardless of how obedient we are, that still doesn't make us deserving of salvation.

Thank you for stopping by.

Unknown said...

Jason...you don't make sense in any way, and I think you know very well you are trying to go in the wrong direction.
You are fooling absolutely no one strong in the faith. I sure hope your days of speaking to young people are over.
You sound like many denominational preachers I knew when I was in a denomination.
You know very well what your doing, and it is wrong!~

FitandRunning said...

Bill (I wish I knew who this was--Bill who?).

In any event, I am truly and generally sorry that you feel so strongly about my post that it would drive you to say these things to me.

I know your intentions are good though. I might have expressed similar sentiments a couple of years ago.

All I can tell you is that I have no intentions to fool anyone. Nor are my intentions to go in a wrong direction, however you might define that. I want nothing more than to be in right direction and have dedicated my life to helping others be on that straight path that leads to righeousness.

I sense a lot of anger and resentment in your post. For that I am sorry. Please continue praying for me, brother. I appreciate your concern.

Unknown said...

I think you know who I am. You have visited in my home.
Anger, resentment,...yes I have both toward a Christian who would lean toward a false doctrine, in an attempt to divide The Church, and be so bold as to teach it to young people.
It is apparent that you learned little in your time at SWSBS. Calvinistic doctrine is designed well, for those who desire to continue in their sins, and not try to grow in The Faith.
Is that why you are trying to justify it?
You need to make some corrections and/or get out of the preaching business.
I am angry and resentful for your attempts to instill false doctrine, but you are still welcome in my home to discuss this, and I pray you will correct your error.

FitandRunning said...

Bill, I have been in a lot of homes of people named Bill. "Bill" is a very common name. However, I think I have figured out who you are. I think this is interesting...very, very interesting.

Since you wish to remain vague and anonymous, I see that this conversation is going nowhere, really. So I guess we're just going to need to leave it here. But let me say a few things, so the record will be straight:

(1)Be honest. Had I posted a blog here on obedience and had not even mentioned one word about grace, would you have gotten on here angry and resentful because I didn't balance this out with grace?

(2)I am not attempting to divide the church. I don't know what gives you a right to say that. Nothing could be further from the truth.

(3)I believe that if we make a mockery of God's grace by completely relying on it in such a way that we think we don't have to be righteous and obedient, then we will be in for a bad, bad time come the day of Judgment (which by the way, I stated in my blog). Of course I believe we have to be obedient. Perhaps it would be wise to go and read another blog I wrote recently before being so quick to pass off judgment: http://www.jasonbrowning.net/2009/01/free-salvation.html

(4)To accuse me of espousing Calvinism and catering to those who "desire to continue in sin" and "not grow in their faith" says a whole lot more about you than it does me.

(5)And I certainly am not "attempting" to instill false doctrine.

If you care to continue this discussion in a mature manner and actually get to the heart of the content of my blog, please contact me at jasoncb71@gmail.com. Otherwise I see nothing fruitful about continuing this type of a dialogue that seems pretty "15-year oldish" to me. It doesn't seem fruitful at all.

Thank you for allowing me in your home. That was very kind of you.

Respectfully,
Jason

Unknown said...

I stand by everything I have said Jason..and I am not wishing to remain anonymous...talk about anger...after your last comment...you should look at yourself.
You've got it...Bill Reed

Anonymous said...

Bill I am shocked with your tone. As a first time read of this particular piece, if I weren't "strong in the faith," it would be your words that would turn me off.

I want you to answer this question please. In Acts 2, what was it that made the 3000 respond in obedience? You and I know what is was, it was the grace of God, aka Jesus the Christ. His life, His message, His death, His resurrection is what produces obedience in the lives of man.

This is all that has been said in this piece.

Clay Martin

Unknown said...

Clay Martin...BE SHOCKED then...I stand by all I have said.....SWSBS should have expelled a few of you boys,along with their director, a long time ago.....B.R.

Anonymous said...

Jason,
I am not a preacher student but rather a preacher who has been preaching 32 years. I am currently working on my Ph. D. The easiest thing to do is preach what people want to hear. If you do this you will go far in the eyes of men. If you challenge the unwritten code you will be chastised by many of our brethren who do not wish to think outside their zone of comfort. If you are of worth as a preacher you will preach Scripture rather than what brethren wish to hear. Preach truth my brother and don't be discouraged by the naysayers and legalists.

Don Morrison said...

Bill said:

"There are many more Scriptures supporting grace through OBEDIENCE."

My question is obedience to what? For which of the commands does God demand perfect obedience, and for which does he offer grace? Does he offer grace for failure to repent? Surely he must, since that is the essence of sin. Does he offer grace for pride? What if I misunderstand some doctrine about the collection or music or who can or cannot pray? Can grace cover those or are they the ones that demand OBEDIENCE? What if all the right words are said at baptism, but I didn't know that I was becoming the bride of Christ: did I receive it in spite of my weak understanding...by grace rather than knowledge?

Which commands, when unknown, neglected or broken can be forgiven and which ones prohibit forgiveness when unknown, neglected or broken?

Anonymous said...

Morrison~
Why don't you back off and read over what you said....Now didn't it sound pretty silly and dumb
It is easy to see you are seeking after your own belly.

You must be like most of these bloggers, wanting to be famous, and scholarly, and consider them selves great preachers, who have discovered all the answers as to "exactly what God means in His Word".

It is in plain black and white...God didn't make it hard for the poor folks, dumb folks, smart folks, rich folks, or anyone else. Grace alone is not taught in The Bible.

The grace offered is through the death of Christ, and tells us we are to obey His word to be saved, and you know it.
Keep going the route your on if you want to tell people what THEY want to hear, rather than what God's word tells and commands us to do.
Bill Reed

Anonymous said...

Hey Bill. I know I'm a little bit late coming in on this conversation, but I think have a great idea. Since SWSBS seems to be producing so many false teachers, maybe it would be best for the kingdom if y'all just shut it down. Whadaya think?